Some more OLPC writeups

Two positive first-person reviews... and a volunteer's blog...

• My Very Own OLPC XO Laptop and an Interview with OLPC's Founding CTO by Groklaw (Pamela Jones), closing with a pointer to...
  
• Hands-on with the OLPC XO and loving it by Joe Barr at Linux.com
• Why XO? by a member of the Support Gang
• Ben Feldman points out flaws, but calls XO his "new mini best friend"
  

More corporate political discussion...

• Why Microsoft Must Control One Laptop Per Child by technorat
• Intel Resigns from Board and
• Laptop Founder Faults Intel -- Wall Street Journal
• Similarly from Sustainable Business Design

Harsh words for little green laptop...

Last week's Economist magazine "Tech View" column had a very negative item about the XO laptop, calling it "clunky," dismissing its developers as "Pollyannaish," and saying the "Give One Get One" program under which I bought mine "fizzled."

Note: After I wrote this page and mentioned the issue on an OLPC wiki, this official reply to the Economist from Walter Bender appeared... or I had simply missed it in my earlier search.

No sources were given for the Economist's "fizzled" comment -- I haven't seen anything elsewhere about the G1G1 program not meeting its goals. As a combination post-beta, charitable contribution and public-relations program, I'd call G1G1 a success -- it got the rumored "One Laptop Per Child" out into adult hands and onto network television screens throughout the U.S. and presumably is financing delivery of thousands of computers to kids...

My XO hasn't failed to attract questions and positive comments at coffee shops in three states -- thanks to G1G1 "bundling" a year's subscription to T-Mobile wifi service. (Most common comment: "How can I get these for my kid's school?") Online, I see more "let's figure it out" and "let's see what we can do" discussions than whining about this all-new device's bugs.

The Economist's reviewer apparently couldn't figure out how to move material between the system's text editor and a Web mail application... I've known a few Windows users who couldn't figure out e-mail attachments with their machines, either. I've been testing the machine with online forums, blog-editing software and Web-based e-mail with reasonable success -- for a machine that really was designed with other things in mind.

I'm not familiar with the other computers the article mentions -- from Intel and other commercial manufacturers, but I suspect that they lack major innovations of the XO, such as its readable-in-daylight reflective screen, its instant "mesh" networking with other XO laptops, its commitment to open-source software, its weatherproof, scratchproof case, and the community of volunteer developers, documenters and testers I've been exploring for the past couple of weeks.

Yes, I had to use the "clunky" Linux underpinnings of the computer to install additional software that American or European adults might want (a more sophisticated Web browser or the ability to play Web videos), but I wasn't expecting a consumer product.

The Economist had no discussion of the music, writing and HyperCard-like EToys programming language software -- or the instant "mesh" networking intended to make it a collaborative classroom workspace for children... without sending participating school systems an annual bill for "software upgrades." That all may be Pollyannish, but I'm waiting to hear how the first year of actual classroom use of the computers works out.

The Economist also moans about "the hubris, arrogance and occasional self-righteousness of OLPC workers." I'm not surprised to find missionaries acting like missionaries, whether they're selling religion, technology or capitalism. I can't imagine anyone using similar terms to describe a crew of Intel and Microsoft salespeople. Heh.

The Economist's Tech View column was accompanied by a Business View piece, The Laptop Wars: Will charity or profit end the digital divide?, about Intel's attempt to sell its small commercial laptop, the ClassMate, in the markets targetted by the not-for-profit XO. The Economist questioned the need for OLPC's idea of "making laptops available cheaply to children in the developing world... as an act of charity," when others believe "there are fortunes to be made designing products for the world’s poorer consumers."

A brief blog item in the Guardian echoes the Economist, but also invites comments. Here's one that caught my eye:

Hate to point out the obvious, but the Economist is not exactly an unbiased referee between the competing philosophies of altruism vs the profit motive, and their realisation in political and economic systems! The Economist is a right-wing publication dedicated to the triumph of corporatism and corporate greed, and the destruction of anything that whiffs vaguely of socialism or doing things for people on a selfless or non-profit-motive basis.

Alas, with my own new semester starting on Monday, I don't have much time to look for responses or discussion... and I will be setting aside my XO for the weekend...

But here are some bookmarks a quick search found; I'll start with them when I get back to the topic:

• Blind to e-book possibilities, the Economist knocks the OLPC machine (from a blog called "TeleRead: Bring the E-Books Home")
• Nomination for worst review by a blogger who also provides a checklist for G1G1 XO users, complete with editorial cartoon aimed at the Economist.
  
• A computer in every pot (an earlier, more positive, Economist article)
• Problems with the $100 laptop is a two-year old article, but the discussion is still going on. Coincidentally, the author designed my first 1982 "portable" computer. More recent items and discussion here and here.
  
• Arahuay, Peru profile is an OLPC report on a village receiving its computers last summer, to contrast with some of the critical evaluations outside the classroom.
  
• Unofficial OLPC News blog
  
• OLPC's own documents are developed in wiki format with a search feature to make up for any organizational problems. These are the pages I'm watching for more discussion: home page, current events page, press clippings page, myth-debunking page, OLPC in the news page, and specific page on its relationship with Intel.

I've decided to be "Robby" throughout the one laptop per child (olpc) online community -- using the nickname that served me well when my hands were as small as those the little green xo computer is intended for.

Here's Robby's olpc bio page, with links to olpc forums, wiki pages and interesting projects -- including the idea of adapting a journalism tutorial originally written for senior citizens with pens and 1990s' computers to one for children with little green 21st Century laptops.

Happy New Year from a small green keyboard in the sun!

I've returned to my oldest existing blog space to test the OLPC XO laptop and its browser (called "Browse") as tools for blog posting and editing. If you're reading this, the combination of XO and online editing works... and may inspire me to use this blog (or this one) more than my "main" one called Other Journalism, which depends on software that I've stuck with for years, but that isn't available for the XO.

The experience: I started writing this while sitting on my sunny back porch with the XO screen in "reflective" mode, which seemed appropriate for a New Year essay inspired by this New York Times article. The sun felt good and the screen was perfectly readable, but windchill affected my typing fingers enough to drive me indoors.

Even with cold fingers, I seem to be getting used to typing on the little green chicklet keyyboard. While it's too small for 10-finger touch typing, I've found a modified six-finger approach works. My breakthough was deciding to leave my thumbs out of it and assign my right index finger to the space bar. The six-finger "home" position that works for me is adf lkn (instead of asdf ;lkj). My typing teacher back at Post Junior College would be horrified.

Back to the business of blogging, which generally involves linking and quoting as well as typing one's own thoughts and observations:

• The XO can open more than one Browse activity at a time and can switch between them with a press of the alt-tab keys.
• Copy and paste work between those pages, so I was able to insert the Times link above and a block of quoted text from the New Year story that inspired this whole exercise.

The ideal New Year’s Eve party would come with a psychological voucher, redeemable the next day for a post-mortem session with friends. A chance to relish the night’s humiliations, take bets on who went home with whom, and nominate the guest most in need of therapy, present company included.

An opportunity, that is, to forestall the traditional morning-after descent into self-examination, that lonely echo chamber of what should and could be.

For me, this XO blog examination was sufficiently therapeutic... lonely echochamber or not... Now, off into the new year...

(Note: I was able to add text attributes like italic, the bullet list and color using Blogger's "Compose" view of the page, but did most of the writing and editing in "Edit HTML" mode, because the rich-text "Compose" view renders the XO browser's I-beam cursor invisible, just as it does in in Gmail's rich-text view. I suspect the XO Browse team has that on its bug list. I came back later and added the XO image, as well as deleting some stray space around the indented paragraphs.)

One Laptop Per Child blogging

I just remembered that the template I was using for this blog is similar to the color of my new One Laptop Per Child xo computer... Maybe that's a sign that I should do some blogging with and about it here...

For now, I've mostly been posting in olpc forums and bookmarking pages, including some good YouTube videos, at http://del.icio.us/bstepno/olpc

I also tried using the xo browser with WordPress at my other server-based blog, Red Liner

Thanks to a new blogger on my bookmark list, I poked into my own old Blogger account today for the first time in a year... I'd missed the whole "new Blogger" transition that merged the login for Blogger and the one for gmail e-mail accounts. Google is certainly trying to take over my life... So far I've given in to these:

• gmail
• iGoogle
• Google Reader
• Orkut
  
• Blogger

The last three have slipped off my radar, replaced by other RSS aggregators, social networking applications and blogging software... Actually, I think I started using Userland's Radio for my blog before trying Blogger. I liked the security of Radio, which runs on my computer and automatically stores a full copy of everything I post at my main space: Bob's Other Journalism Weblog.

Back when I first tried Blogger, I wasn't sure I could trust it to be around for long. Maybe it's safe to use now. :-)

Speaking of safety, I see a word balloon below this window that says "Now Blogger saves your drafts automatically!" -- which is something I wish all Web-based writing programs did. I wonder whether that's available as a module in WordPress, Drupal, Manila or Django, the other publishing engines I have used for "demo" blogs?

I suspect Blogger also has a "backup the full contents of your blog" feature somewhere. If so, I'd have no reservations left about using it as my "most frequent" blog, since I could post from any of the seven computers I use. I'll think about it...

bstepno's bookmarks on del.icio.us
... are where I've been keeping a lot of the "for possible reference later" posts that I used to put in this Blogger blog after starting my Other Journalism Weblog.

(Also known as Couranteer.com)